Hiring the right candidate is one of the most critical tasks for any organization, but the process can be draining—especially when conducting multiple interviews in a single day. Many hiring managers believe that interviewing more candidates will lead to better hires, but this approach often backfires. Interview fatigue doesn’t just affect candidates; it’s a significant issue for hiring managers too. When exhaustion sets in, your ability to evaluate candidates objectively diminishes, potentially costing you the perfect hire. In this article, we’ll explore five practical tips to combat interview fatigue and improve your hiring outcomes, ensuring you stay sharp, focused, and energized throughout the process.
The Hidden Cost of Interview Fatigue
Interview fatigue occurs when the mental and emotional demands of conducting multiple interviews overwhelm a hiring manager’s ability to make clear, objective decisions. As the day progresses, details from earlier interviews blur, energy levels drop, and evaluations become less consistent. This can lead to snap judgments, missed red flags, or even overlooking an exceptional candidate simply because you’re too tired to notice their potential. The good news? With a few strategic adjustments to your hiring process, you can minimize fatigue and make better hiring decisions. Let’s dive into the five tips that will help you stay on top of your game.
Tip 1: Start with Phone Screens to Filter Candidates
One of the most effective ways to reduce interview fatigue is to implement a phone screening process before inviting candidates for in-person or video interviews. A 15- to 20-minute phone call allows you to quickly assess whether a candidate meets the basic qualifications and aligns with the role’s requirements. This step acts as a gatekeeper, filtering out candidates who are clearly not a fit and saving you from spending an hour or more on interviews that are unlikely to lead to a hire.
Phone screens are efficient because they focus on key criteria, such as technical skills, experience, or cultural fit, without requiring the time and energy of a full interview. By narrowing down your candidate pool early, you can dedicate your energy to evaluating only the most promising candidates in greater depth. This approach not only saves time but also helps you maintain mental clarity for the interviews that matter most.
Tip 2: Limit Interviews Per Day
It’s tempting to pack as many interviews as possible into a single day to speed up the hiring process, but this can lead to diminishing returns. Research suggests that decision-making quality declines after a certain number of repetitive tasks, and interviews are no exception. To combat this, limit yourself to no more than three focused interviews per day. Beyond this threshold, details from earlier conversations may start to blur, and your ability to assess candidates accurately can suffer.
By capping the number of interviews, you give yourself the mental space to fully engage with each candidate, take detailed notes, and reflect on their qualifications. This approach ensures that every candidate gets a fair evaluation, free from the haze of exhaustion. If you have a large pool of candidates, spread the interviews across multiple days to maintain your focus and energy.
Read More: Reclaim Your Time: How to Say No at Work
Tip 3: Space Out Finalist Interviews
When you’ve narrowed down your candidate pool to a handful of top contenders, it’s tempting to schedule all their interviews back-to-back for easy comparison. However, this can overload your mental capacity and make it harder to distinguish between candidates. Instead, schedule your finalist interviews on different days. Spacing out these high-stakes evaluations allows you to approach each candidate with a fresh perspective, free from the mental clutter of comparing them in rapid succession.
This strategy also gives you time to reflect on each finalist’s strengths and weaknesses, consult with colleagues, and review your notes before making a final decision. By spreading out finalist interviews, you’ll be better equipped to assess each candidate on their own merits, leading to a more confident and informed hiring decision.
Tip 4: Set Clear Evaluation Criteria
One of the biggest challenges of conducting multiple interviews is maintaining objectivity, especially when fatigue sets in. To stay consistent, establish clear evaluation criteria before you begin interviewing. These criteria should be specific, measurable, and directly tied to the role’s requirements. For example, if you’re hiring a software engineer, your criteria might include technical expertise, problem-solving skills, and collaboration ability. By defining these standards upfront, you create a framework that keeps your evaluations focused and fair, even when you’re tired.
Stick to your criteria throughout the process, and use a standardized scoring system or checklist to evaluate each candidate. This reduces the risk of subjective biases creeping in and ensures that you’re comparing candidates based on the same benchmarks. Clear criteria act as an anchor, helping you make objective decisions no matter how many interviews you’ve conducted.
Tip 5: Reset Your Energy Before Each Interview
Hiring managers are human, and even the most disciplined professionals can feel drained after a long day of interviews. To counteract this, incorporate an energy reset ritual before each interview to refresh your focus and mindset. A simple yet effective technique is to plant your feet firmly on the floor, take three deep breaths, and repeat a positive affirmation, such as: “I am clear, I am focused, I am ready to meet my next great hire.” This practice helps you center yourself and approach each interview with renewed energy.
For an added boost, consider keeping a small object, like a citrine crystal, on your desk as a visual reminder to stay mentally sharp. Citrine is often associated with clarity and positivity, and having a tangible cue can reinforce your intention to stay engaged. By resetting your energy, you’ll be better equipped to connect with candidates, ask insightful questions, and make thoughtful evaluations.
Putting It All Together
Interview fatigue is a silent saboteur that can undermine even the most well-intentioned hiring process. By implementing these five tips—using phone screens, limiting daily interviews, spacing out finalists, setting clear criteria, and resetting your energy—you can maintain your focus, objectivity, and enthusiasm throughout the hiring process. These strategies not only reduce fatigue but also increase the likelihood of identifying and securing the right candidate for the role.
Hiring is both an art and a science, requiring a balance of intuition, structure, and stamina. By optimizing your approach to interviews, you’ll create a more efficient and effective process that benefits both you and your candidates. The result? A stronger team, better hires, and a hiring process that feels less like a marathon and more like a purposeful journey toward finding the perfect fit.
So, the next time you’re gearing up for a round of interviews, take a moment to plan strategically. Use phone screens to streamline your candidate pool, limit daily interviews to preserve your energy, space out finalists for clarity, define clear criteria for consistency, and reset your energy to stay engaged. With these tools in your arsenal, you’ll be well on your way to making smarter, more confident hiring decisions—without the fog of interview fatigue clouding your judgment.
Read More: Job Interview Fatigue: 6 Easy Feng Shui Tips to Overcome